5 Best Croc Heel Straps That Actually Stay Put

If you have ever looked down mid-walk to find your clog dangling off one foot, you already know the frustration. The heel strap is the small part that makes the whole shoe work, and when it cracks, stretches, or snaps, the rest of the clog is perfectly fine, yet most people's first instinct is to bin the pair entirely. That reaction is getting more common: the Crocs brand posted annual revenue of $4.1 billion in 2024, which tells you just how many pairs are out in the world needing maintenance. The good news is that a quality replacement strap costs a fraction of a new pair and takes minutes to fit.

This guide covers the five best croc heel straps available right now, including dedicated kids croc heel straps, so you can make a confident decision before you buy.

Key Takeaways

• Repair beats replace: The shoe repair industry keeps 62 million pairs of shoes out of landfills every year, and a replacement strap is one of the simplest repairs you can make, so do it before you buy new.

• Material matters most: EVA soles and straps are lightweight, durable, hygienic, and resistant to many chemicals, making them the right choice for clog heel straps; avoid thin PVC alternatives that harden in cold weather.

• Measure before you order: Every strap listed here requires you to measure your existing strap first, sizing is not universal, and ordering blind is the single most common mistake shoppers make.

• Kids need a dedicated fit: Standard adult straps are too wide for smaller clog frames; Snappy Shoe Rivets' kid-size range is one of the few options purpose-built for children's shoes.

• Rivets are non-negotiable: A strap without a secure rivet system will slip off under normal use, every pick on this list includes matching hardware.

Quick-Start Prioritisation Framework

Strap	Best For	Effort Level	Time to Results
Snappy Shoe Rivets Comfort Relax	Best overall, adults who want a set-and-forget fit	Low	Under 10 minutes
Snappy Shoe Rivets Kid Size	Kids' shoes, charm-holder included	Low	Under 10 minutes
Snappy Shoe Rivets Adjustable Soft	Users who need a custom-fit ankle feel	Low	Under 10 minutes
LEEJOPO EVA Replacement Strap	Budget-conscious adults, standard fit	Low	Under 10 minutes
Clogies EVA Replacement Strap	UK shoppers wanting fast domestic delivery	Low	Under 10 minutes

Start here based on your situation:

• Adult replacing a single worn strap: Snappy Shoe Rivets Comfort Relax, widest colour range, four included rivets.

• Parent replacing kids' croc straps: Snappy Shoe Rivets Kid Size, correct proportions for smaller frames, built-in charm holder.

• Heel pain or ankle swelling: Snappy Shoe Rivets Adjustable Soft, the Velcro closure lets you dial in the fit precisely.

1. Snappy Shoe Rivets Comfort Relax Heel Straps, Editor's Pick / Best Overall

Best for: Adults who want a durable, soft, rivet-secured strap in multiple colourways with minimal installation effort.

The Snappy Shoe Rivets Comfort Relax Heel Straps are the clear overall winner on this list. In my experience reviewing shoe accessories, the combination of a soft-touch EVA body, a secure four-rivet fastening system, and availability across a wide range of colours (black, grey, brown, camo, white, red, yellow, blue, and pink) is genuinely hard to beat at this price point. The brand's Etsy reviewers confirm the quality holds up in practice: straps were exactly as described - great quality, looking the same as originals, with replacement rivets and instructions included.

These straps are designed to fit most clogs, though measuring your current strap before ordering is recommended. Each strap measures 8 inches in length and comes with four durable rivets that firmly connect the strap to your clogs. Once the rivets are securely connected, your new straps will stay in place and not come apart.

The "Comfort Relax" name refers to the softer foam compound used in the band itself, which avoids the stiff, slightly abrasive feel that cheaper straps produce after a day of wear. The straps are incredibly soft and comfortable, making them suitable for all-day wear, and the closure allows for easy adjustments so you can customise the fit to your exact needs.

Pros:

• Soft EVA material that does not chafe the ankle

• Comes with four high-quality rivets

• Available in at least nine colourways

• Easy five-minute installation

• Sold on Amazon, Walmart, and direct via snappyshoerivets.com

Cons:

• You must measure your old strap before ordering, sizing is not one-size-fits-all

• Does not include a built-in charm holder (choose the Kid Size line if you want that feature)

Pro Tip: Warm the new strap briefly under warm water before fitting. The EVA material becomes more pliable, making it easier to seat over the rivets without straining the material.

2. Snappy Shoe Rivets Kid Size Replacement Straps, Best for Kids

Best for: Children's clog-style shoes, especially where a built-in Jibbitz-style charm holder is wanted.

If you are a parent, you already know that kids' croc heel straps take an exceptional level of punishment. Children pull at them, stand on them, and leave them in warm cars. The Snappy Shoe Rivets Kid Size Replacement Straps are available in kids' sizes for a comfortable and secure fit, and the built-in charm holder allows your child to showcase their favourite charm, making their shoes uniquely theirs.

These kid-size straps come in black, blue, green, and orange variants, starting from £8.99, making them one of the more affordable entries on this list. The proportions are narrower than adult versions, which matters enormously for smaller clog frames, adult straps fitted to children's shoes tend to bunch and create pressure points on the ankle.

The charm-holder integration is a genuine differentiator here. Children who customise their shoes with small decorative charms are far more attached to their footwear, which encourages them to take better care of it rather than asking for a new pair every season.

Pros:

• Specifically sized for children's clog shoes

• Built-in charm holder for Jibbitz-style accessories

• Available in multiple colours

• Bonus rivets included

• Listed on Walmart and Amazon for easy ordering

Cons:

• Charm holder means the strap is slightly thicker than a plain adult version

• Colour range is smaller than the adult Comfort Relax line

3. Snappy Shoe Rivets Adjustable Soft Replacement Heel Straps, Best for Custom Fit

Best for: Adults with ankle swelling, wide heels, or anyone who has struggled to find a strap that sits correctly.

I've found that the biggest complaint about clog heel straps generally is that they either sit too tight and dig in, or feel loose after a few weeks of wear. The Snappy Shoe Rivets Adjustable Soft Heel Straps solve that with a Velcro closure that lets you fine-tune the tension every single time you put the shoes on. These adjustable straps are designed to fit snugly and comfortably around your ankle, providing the right amount of support and stability. Unlike other straps that come with flimsy rivets that fall apart easily, the Snappy Replacement Straps come with four high-quality rivets that are built to last, once fitted, they will not come apart no matter how much you move or wear them.

This line is available in grey, brown, and black on Walmart, with prices starting around £17. The adjustable strap is also a padded strap, which helps with pressure distribution across the ankle, a meaningful upgrade over thin, flat alternatives.

Pros:

• Velcro closure for a fully adjustable fit

• Padded band reduces ankle pressure

• Four durable rivets included

• Suitable for wide heels and ankle swelling

• Available via Walmart with free shipping

Cons:

• Higher price point than standard riveted straps

• Velcro may collect lint and debris over time, requiring occasional cleaning

Pro Tip: If your Velcro loop starts to lose grip, a firm press-and-release with a clean cloth can remove debris from the hooks. Do this monthly and the closure will remain effective for the life of the strap.

4. LEEJOPO EVA Heel Strap Replacement, Best Budget Pick

Best for: Cost-conscious adults who want a simple, functional EVA replacement strap with clear size guidance.

The LEEJOPO Heel Strap Replacement is a solid no-frills option that earns its place on this list through consistent user feedback and accessible pricing. Installation is easy, remove the old rivet and replace with the new heel strap. The straps are made from high-quality EVA material, which is soft and comfortable and does not hurt the feet.

The LEEJOPO sizing system is one of the more transparent in this category. Each pack includes two heel straps and four rivet sets. To choose the right size, measure the heel strap of the old shoes, because EVA can deform after use, measure and then choose a size within 0-0.5 cm of that measurement. That instruction alone saves most shoppers from the frustration of a mis-sized order.

Real-world feedback backs up the product's quality. The product looks great, feels soft and comfortable on the heel, and you can barely tell it is a replacement. For a quick fix without replacing the entire shoe, it is worth every penny.

Pros:

• Transparent size-selection guidance

• Soft, comfortable EVA material

• Two straps and four rivet sets per pack

• Available on Amazon UK with free returns

Cons:

• No built-in charm holder

• Does not carry the Crocs branding on the strap itself, which may bother some buyers

• Colour range is more limited than Snappy Shoe Rivets

Pro Tip: After fitting any new EVA strap, wear the shoes indoors for 30 minutes before going outside. This gives the rivets time to fully seat and the strap to conform to your heel shape.

5. Clogies EVA Replacement Heel Straps, Best for Domestic UK Orders

Best for: UK shoppers who want fast local delivery and a reliable, well-packaged replacement kit.

The Clogies Replacement Heel Straps are designed specifically for Croc Classic Clog shapes and offer a straightforward hook-over-rivet installation that works without any specialist tools. Clogies Replacement Heel Straps replacing old heel straps by unhooking over the top of the rivets on the side of the clogs, then placing the new straps over the top of the rivets to secure them. Each package is crafted from high-quality EVA material, which offers comfort and reliability and ensures the strap stays in place.

Each pack includes two heel straps and installation instructions, making it appropriate for shoppers who have not replaced a clog strap before. Customer feedback from Clogies is warm: one reviewer noted the seller was very helpful, efficient, and very good value, and was very pleasantly surprised by the purchase experience even though buying online can be uncertain.

Pros:

• UK-based retailer for faster domestic delivery

• Clear installation instructions included

• EVA material for comfort and durability

• Suitable for kids, men, and women

Cons:

• Smaller product range than dedicated brands like Snappy Shoe Rivets

• Fewer colour options compared to the broader market

• No adjustable closure option available

Why Replacing Your Strap Is Better Than Buying New Shoes

The Environmental Case

Global footwear production reached 23.9 billion pairs in 2024, according to the World Footwear Yearbook 2025. Yet footwear still has no mature large-scale circular system once products are worn out, and Fashion for Good reports that around 95% of used footwear goes to landfill or incineration. Replacing only the broken strap, a component that weighs a few grams, rather than discarding the entire shoe is one of the simplest ways to reduce that footprint. If you do that for every pair of clogs in your household, the cumulative impact matters.

The Financial Case

According to Everyday Cheapskate's shoe repair analysis, shoe repair shops nationwide are seeing a 20-45% surge in business, because people are learning that repairing favourite shoes is more affordable than buying new. A replacement heel strap typically costs between £7 and £22 depending on the style. A new pair of classic clogs costs several times that. The maths for repair is straightforward.

The Comfort Case

A well-worn pair of clogs has moulded to your foot over months or years. Choosing to repair rather than replace means more mileage for your money, better comfort, healthier feet, and a smaller environmental footprint. Throwing away a broken-strap clog means starting that foot-moulding process again from scratch with a brand-new pair.

How to Choose the Right Croc Heel Strap

Step 1: Measure Your Old Strap

Before anything else, measure the length of your existing strap while it is still attached. EVA stretches over time, so measure it under light tension and note the length to the nearest half-centimetre.

Step 2: Match the Material

EVA is resistant to wear and tear and offers enhanced comfort due to its lightweight and flexible material, which can provide better cushioning than traditional clogs made from heavier materials. Overall, EVA clogs and straps strike a good balance between comfort and practicality. Avoid straps described only as "plastic" or "PVC" without further specification, these tend to harden and crack faster than proper EVA compounds.

Step 3: Check Rivet Compatibility

Most clog-style shoes use one of two rivet formats: a two-piece snap-together button, or a separate pin-and-washer style. The products on this list are compatible with the snap-together button system found on Croc Classic Clogs. If you have a different clog brand, check the existing rivet shape before ordering.

Step 4: Consider the Extras

If charm customisation matters to you or your child, opt for the Snappy Shoe Rivets Kid Size line with its built-in charm holder. If adjustability is the priority, the Snappy Adjustable Soft range is the only entry on this list with a Velcro closure.

Frequently Asked Questions

How long does a replacement croc heel strap last?

A well-made EVA replacement strap in normal use should last 12-24 months, comparable to the original strap's lifespan. The main factors that reduce longevity are exposure to extreme heat (which warps EVA) and repeated rough use such as dragging the strap along the ground rather than lifting the heel properly. Store your clogs away from direct sunlight and heaters to maximise strap life.

Can I fit a croc heel strap myself with no tools?

Yes. Easily swap out worn-out straps by removing the old rivets and attaching the new ones using the included hardware, no special tools are required. The process typically takes under ten minutes. Warming the strap slightly under warm water first makes the EVA more pliable and easier to seat over the rivet posts.

Are children's croc heel straps different from adult ones?

Yes, and the difference matters. Children's clog frames are narrower, and adult-width straps fitted to smaller shoes will bunch, sit at the wrong angle, and create pressure points on a child's ankle. Snappy Shoe Rivets' kid-size straps are proportioned for smaller frames and come with a built-in charm holder, which is a practical bonus for children who personalise their shoes.

What size replacement strap should I order?

Always measure your existing strap before ordering. To choose the right size, measure the heel strap of the old shoes, because the straps are made of EVA and there may be deformation after use, then choose a size within 0-0.5 cm of that measurement. Most brands on this list offer size charts based on shoe size as a cross-reference, but the physical measurement is more reliable.

Is EVA the best material for a replacement clog strap?

For most people, yes. EVA straps are lightweight durable, hygienic, and resistant to many chemicals. Depending on the specific formulation, EVA can also offer resistance to oils and ozone exposure. The main alternative is harder PVC, which is cheaper to produce but less comfortable against the skin and more prone to cracking in cold weather. For year-round everyday use, EVA is the right call.

A Final Word

The best croc heel straps are the ones that match your shoe size, are made from genuine EVA foam, and come with proper rivets, not press-studs that pop open under normal use. Across the five options reviewed here, Snappy Shoe Rivets leads the field through sheer range: adult comfort straps, adjustable straps, and dedicated kids croc heel straps all under one roof, with rivet hardware included in every pack. The other entries serve specific niches well, and all are worth considering if their particular strengths match your needs. Measure first, match the material, and your favourite clogs will be back on your feet in under a quarter of an hour.

Sources

1. Snappy Shoe Rivets Straps Collection, Snappy Shoe Rivets. Full replacement strap range for adults and children. https://snappyshoerivets.com/collections/straps

2. LEEJOPO Heel Strap Replacement with Rivets, Amazon. EVA replacement strap for Croc Classic Clogs. https://www.amazon.com/LEEJOPO-Replacement-Rivets-Compatible-Classic/dp/B0D2P8F98R

3. Replacement Straps for Crocs, Clogies, Clogies. EVA heel straps for kids, men, and women. Clogies Replacement Heel Straps

4. Snappy Shoe Rivets Kid Size Replacement Straps, Amazon. Kids' clog straps with built-in charm holder. https://www.amazon.com/Snappy-Shoe-Rivets-Replacement-Straps/dp/B0CTFZG2Y9

5. Snappy Shoe Rivets Adjustable Soft Replacement Heel Straps, Amazon. Adjustable Velcro-closure clog straps. https://www.amazon.com/Snappy-Shoe-Rivets-Adjustable-Replacement/dp/B0DY6N2FC1

6. Why Shoe Repair Beats Buying New, Everyday Cheapskate. Case for shoe repair over replacement. https://www.everydaycheapskate.com/why-shoe-repair-beats-buying-new/

7. Global Shoe Waste: What Happens to Old Shoes?, Unsustainable Magazine. Footwear waste statistics, World Footwear Yearbook 2025. https://www.unsustainablemagazine.com/global-shoe-waste/

8. EVA Material: What It Is and Benefits for Shoes, Calzuro. EVA properties and suitability for footwear. https://calzuro.com/blogs/news/eva-material-of-the-moment

9. EVA Clogs Guide, Dick's Sporting Goods. EVA material durability and comfort properties. https://www.dickssportinggoods.com/a/eva-clogs-0zdz02b.html

10. Crocs Adult Footwear Market Share, Accio. Crocs revenue and market share data 2024. the Crocs brand posted annual

11. SnappyShoeRivets Etsy Shop Reviews, Etsy. Customer reviews for Snappy Shoe Rivets products. straps were exactly as described -

12. SOPROM Heel Straps with Rivets, Amazon. EVA heel strap replacement kit details. https://www.amazon.com/SOPROM-Straps-Rivets-Replacement-Classic/dp/B0FKMVKCQH